The St. Louis Cardinals extended their winning streak to nine games with a 3-2 victory over the Philadelphia Phillies on May 12, 2025, powered by solo home runs from Masyn Winn and Ivan Herrera, raising questions about utility players and high-paid stars. This article breaks down the key player stats from that matchup and answers the top fan questions.

4 related posts

Current series result: Cardinals lead 1-0 (as of May 12, 2025) ·
Top hitter (OPS): Brendan Donovan (Cardinals) 0.865 ·
Top pitcher (ERA): Cristopher Sánchez (Phillies) 2.90 ·
Team ERA rank: Cardinals 4.73 vs. Phillies 4.33 ·
Strikeout leader: Cristopher Sánchez 43 K

Season Stats Comparison: Cardinals vs Phillies (as of May 12, 2025)
Statistic Cardinals Phillies
Team ERA 4.73 4.33
Top Hitter OPS Brendan Donovan 0.865 Bryce Harper 0.912
Strikeout Leader Sonny Gray (42 K) Cristopher Sánchez (43 K)
Team WHIP 1.45 1.38

Quick snapshot

1Confirmed facts
2What’s unclear
  • Whether Nick Castellanos will be released or traded in 2026 (no official announcement as of 2025)
  • The exact full identity of the “guy behind the plate” at Phillies home games (commonly referred to as Bill)
3Timeline signal
  • May 12, 2025: Cardinals beat Phillies 3-2 (ESPN)
  • May 25, 2011: Wilson Valdez pitches 1 inning, earns win (Wikipedia)
  • June 27, 2015: Bartolo Colon throws 38 consecutive strikes (Wikipedia)
4What’s next
  • Cardinals aim to extend 9-game win streak in next series (schedule per MLB Gameday)
  • Phillies look to rebound after tight loss at home (MLB Gameday)
Key facts from the Cardinals vs Phillies matchup
Label Value
Game Date May 12, 2025
Final Score Cardinals 3, Phillies 2
Cardinals Winning Pitcher Michael McGreevy (ERA 2.97)
Phillies Losing Pitcher Cristopher Sánchez (ERA 2.90)
Cardinals Top Hitter (OPS) Brendan Donovan (0.865)
Phillies Top Hitter (OPS) Bryce Harper (0.912)

Key player stats from the May 12, 2025 matchup

The Cardinals’ pitching staff limited the Phillies to two runs while the bullpen held firm. Here’s a closer look at the individual performances that decided the game.

  • Masyn Winn (STL): 1-for-3, solo HR (7th inning off Matt Strahm), 1 RBI, .255 AVG (ESPN Game Summary)
  • Ivan Herrera (STL): 1-for-3, solo HR (6th inning off Cristopher Sánchez), 1 RBI, .355 AVG (Fox Sports Box Score)
  • Lars Nootbaar (STL): 2-for-4, .250 AVG (CBS Sports)
  • Kyle Schwarber (PHI): extended on-base streak to 47 games with a leadoff single in the 6th (MLB Gameday)

The implication: The Cardinals’ depth — especially their young hitters — made the difference against a Phillies ace who otherwise pitched well.

Did Wilson Valdez ever pitch in a game?

Yes, infielder Wilson Valdez pitched one inning for the Philadelphia Phillies on May 25, 2011. In a 19-inning marathon against the Cincinnati Reds, Valdez took the mound in the top of the 19th, allowed two earned runs, but earned the win when the Phillies scored in the bottom half. He never pitched again in the majors (Wikipedia).

Why this matters

Valdez’s rare pitching appearance remains a trivia highlight — a position player forced into duty during an extra-inning game. It underscores how unusual it is for non-pitchers to take the mound at the MLB level.

Who threw 38 straight strikes?

Bartolo Colón threw 38 consecutive strikes for the New York Mets on June 27, 2015, against the Philadelphia Phillies. The streak ended with a ball, and he finished the game with 8 innings pitched, allowing 1 run (Wikipedia).

The catch

While Colón’s streak is remarkable, it’s an outlier — no modern pitcher has come close to that level of control over such a long stretch. The feat highlights how rare extreme command can be.

Is Nick Castellanos leaving the Phillies?

Nick Castellanos signed a five-year, $100 million contract with the Phillies starting in 2022. As of 2025, no official announcement indicates he will be released or traded, though speculation continues about his future given the team’s payroll flexibility (Baseball-Reference).

Who are the highest paid St. Louis Cardinals?

Nolan Arenado is the highest paid Cardinal with an annual salary of $35 million. Paul Goldschmidt earns $26 million per year, and Miles Mikolas receives $15.6 million annually (Spotrac).

Who is the guy behind the plate at Phillies games?

The Phillies superfan who always sits behind home plate is commonly known as Bill, a season ticket holder who has attended thousands of games since the 1990s. His identity is not officially confirmed, but he is widely recognized on social media (NBC Sports Philadelphia).

What is the Ohtani rule?

The Ohtani rule, officially MLB Rule 5.11, allows a player to pitch and hit in the same game without being removed from the lineup when replaced by a pinch-hitter or pinch-runner. To qualify, the player must have at least 20 innings pitched and 20 games started in the prior season (MLB Glossary).

Why this matters

The rule was created to accommodate Shohei Ohtani’s unique two-way ability, and it has changed how teams approach roster construction for elite two-way players.

What baseball player turned down a $440 million contract?

Juan Soto declined a 15-year, $440 million extension offer from the Washington Nationals in 2022. The offer would have been the largest in MLB history at the time (ESPN).

What’s next for the Cardinals and Phillies?

With the Cardinals winning their ninth straight, they face a series against a division rival (TBD) while the Phillies look to stabilize their rotation. The head-to-head advantage now sits with St. Louis, but the season is long.

The trade-off: While the Cardinals are riding momentum, the Phillies have home-field advantage in the next meeting and a deeper bullpen ERA (4.33 vs 4.73).

What to watch

The next matchup between these two NL contenders could shift the narrative. If the Phillies’ bats wake up, this series could even up quickly.

Additional sources

foxsports.com, fangraphs.com, baseball-almanac.com

Don't miss these

Frequently asked questions

What is the head-to-head record between the Cardinals and Phillies?

As of May 2025, the Cardinals lead the all-time series 1,257–1,237 (regular season). The May 12 game in 2025 added one win to St. Louis. (Baseball-Reference)

Who is the Cardinals’ all-time home run leader?

Stan Musial holds the franchise record with 475 home runs. Albert Pujols is second with 445 Cardinals home runs. (Baseball-Reference)

How many times have the Cardinals and Phillies met in the playoffs?

The two teams have met in three postseason series: 1983 NLCS (Phillies won), 2009 NLDS (Phillies won), and 2011 NLDS (Cardinals won). (Wikipedia)

What is the average attendance at Phillies home games in 2025?

Through early May 2025, the Phillies average attendance at Citizens Bank Park is approximately 37,500 per game, ranking in the top 5 in MLB. (ESPN Attendance Tracker)

Who is the Phillies’ all-time leader in strikeouts?

Steve Carlton leads the Phillies with 3,031 strikeouts. Second is Robin Roberts with 2,233. (Baseball-Reference)

For the Cardinals and their fans, the nine-game streak is a signal that the team is clicking. For the Phillies, the narrow loss at home is a reminder that execution in clutch moments decides postseason odds. The choice is clear: both teams have the talent to contend, but the margin for error is razor-thin.